Why Bloggers Shouldn’t Automate Social Bookmarking

by Diana Freedman on November 30, 2008

Automated Bookmarking

Social Marker looks like an awesome tool at first. It’s a website which makes the process of social bookmarking faster. Instead of having to visit each individual bookmarking site, you can scroll though 47 different submission pages within one iframe. Social Marker claims that this process will make search engines notice you a lot more since so many websites would be pointing to your website.

There’s also plenty of software out there to automate social bookmarking; all you have to do is enter the URL you’d like to bookmark. What a time-saver, right? Wrong. While sites like Social Marker are useful in theory, this is also known as spamming. But this isn’t just an ethical issue.

Social Marker could get you bannned from google and bookmarking sites.

Search engines penalize spammers

Google, Yahoo, and other search engines use algorithms that recognize systematic spammers, including those who spam the social bookmarking sites. When you use a common tool like social marker, you’ll end up wasting a lot of time trying to promote your blog because the search engines will not rank you well when they recognize your spamming patterns. This obviously can have a negative effect on your website, and it could be permanent.

Social bookmarking sites ban spammers

Sites like StumbleUpon, Digg, and Delicious will ban your account, and even your IP address if they recognize that you are spamming their site for self-promotion. Participating in stumble/digg exchanges will also put your account at risk. According to StumbleUpon’s terms of service: “The practice of sending PM’s encouraging or inviting other stumblers to rate/review sites in exchange for reciprocal reviews/ratings, monetary, or any other form of reward is strictly forbidden.”

And not only can your account be banned for participating in exchange ratings, but your website can be permanently banned from being rated or reviewed. This isn’t worth the risk. Social bookmarking, when used properly, is such a valuable tool for getting valuable traffic to your site.

Don’t submit only your own content

You can still utilize social bookmarking sites to get meaningful traffic to your site without exploiting the system. Submit articles from blogs similar to yours, and write meaningful reviews that include your signature (name and URL). When the blog owners sees your review, they may go to your website and return the favor. The review you’ll receive in return will be much more valuable than if you’d participated in a stumble-exchange review: “Great!”

Being an active user of these social bookmarking sites doesn’t have to be time consuming. Most of their homepages include recently popular pages. So check out a few, and rate the ones that you found interesting. This way, if you have written an article you’re really proud of and want to get into the system, you can bookmark your own content once in a rare while without looking like a spammer.

Make it easy for visitors to bookmark your blog

Encourage your visitors to bookmark your site and articles by providing links to quickly stumble or digg your site. You can see my bookmark-icon links at the bottom of each post. Wordpress and Typepad have widgets you can install that automatically add these links to each one of your articles. Add To Any is also a great widget that you can add to any site, and it’s really easy to configure and install. Don’t overwhelm your users with links to share your URL all over the place, but make the links easily visible on the page.

There are so many articles out there promoting sites like Social Marker, claiming that it can save bloggers so much time when marketing their blog. So if you still think that Social Marker is a valuable resource and want to use it, use it sparingly and only for your best posts. But decide first whether you think it’s worth the risk, because once your website is banned, it will be too late to change your mind. Also, decide if you really need to be submitting your content to 47 different sites. You’re probably better off  becoming an active user a few sites, constantly using them to submit interesting articles on the web, occasionally including your own.

So what do you think? Do you use social bookmarking tools like Social Marker? Do you think automating the process and self-promotion should be treated so harshly?

Related Posts:

Article by Diana Freedman

Diana Freedman is the founder of ustandout.com, a guide for making your web presence stand out using social media and other web marketing tactics. Diana works in advertising as an Account Executive in Boston. Start socializing with Diana by following her on Twitter.


Like this post? Want more from U Stand Out? Subscribe via RSS to get updated with all the latest content.


Comments on this entry are closed.

{ 12 comments }

Hisham November 30, 2008 at 8:57 am

My social bookmarking strategy started with bookmarking my articles and submitting them to social networks (digg, blogcatalog, delicious, furl mixx, etc..) but that was at the beginning.

Now I think more open about it, so I have my own community that I use to promote not just my blogs and my articles but also my active friends as I featured one blog every week to git the most hits from My Life Thinking community, it works for me just fine.

Good luck!

Atif November 30, 2008 at 5:22 pm

Thanks for sharing.
Which are the best social booking sites out there?
I usually send my links to Digg, Reditt, StumbleUpon, Mixx, Yahoo Buzz.

Out of them I get hits from Reditt occasionally. But when it is, it's 50+. Then a few from Yahoo Buzz and Mixx. Very rarely from Digg and StumbleUpon.

How can I improve on this? And is there any other site that I'm missing on?

Atif November 30, 2008 at 6:22 pm

Thanks for sharing.
Which are the best social booking sites out there?
I usually send my links to Digg, Reditt, StumbleUpon, Mixx, Yahoo Buzz.

Out of them I get hits from Reditt occasionally. But when it is, it's 50+. Then a few from Yahoo Buzz and Mixx. Very rarely from Digg and StumbleUpon.

How can I improve on this? And is there any other site that I'm missing on?

Blog for Beginners December 4, 2008 at 5:49 am

Well, I’m not one who is fond of social sites and for that matter, I don’t submit or automate the submission. Maybe it’s just me but traffic from social sites don’t really convert well. I could be wrong though….

Yan

Blog for Beginners’s last blog post..10 Tips for a Blog Design Makeover

drivelocity December 11, 2008 at 10:15 pm

It’s also important to provide good comments as well as submitting content from authority sites other than your own. A well thought out or controversial comment that sparks good debate cane get your name out there. I’ve seen one blogger refer to this as something like the bandwagon effect…

drivelocity’s last blog post..Obama Picks Nobel Prize Winning Physicist as Energy Secretary

Cheap Mobile Calls December 12, 2008 at 9:18 am

I don’t think it should be treated so harshly, but unfortunately, I guess there is no other way to treat spammers. Personally, I participate in active blog commenting and social posting all the time. I think it all pays off if you do take the little extra time to do it yourself.

Hisham December 17, 2008 at 6:59 pm

I remember now when I first created “BabelTalk.net” website as a big blog roll for myself, I was linking to all pages I like and also those pages and articles my friends was asking me to link to them. I was submitting all those posts to my network websites, like digg and mixx… etc.. after some time the mixx community started to notice that I was making a big mistake, but the truth was that I didn’t knew that, it was like digging a page to mixx :)

I have put a link for you so you can read my apologize to the mixx world.

anyways I like this post you have here so I will bookmark it, but this time on my own network. thanks again for sharing this nice post and information.

Hisham’s last blog post..Who was Insulted? Bush or the Shoe?

work from home ideas January 3, 2009 at 9:18 pm

Social Bookmarker could still be useful if you don’t submit your own sites or posts. Just ask a group of 6 to submit for you or exchange submissions. If you do this on a small scale, it could still be effective.

Peter Lee

work from home ideas’s last blog post..Who Else Wants Free Backlinks To Their Home Business Blogs

Zippers October 14, 2009 at 12:30 am

Hi,
I'm trying to promote my website by social bookmarking the content on my site? Which social bookmarking site should I spend my time on? And does anyone have any tips on the best practices or strategies for this type of search engine optimization?

Zippers October 14, 2009 at 7:30 am

Hi,
I'm trying to promote my website by social bookmarking the content on my site? Which social bookmarking site should I spend my time on? And does anyone have any tips on the best practices or strategies for this type of search engine optimization?

Discount Purses April 5, 2010 at 12:58 pm

I have to say, every time I come to ustandout.com there is another remarkable article up to read. One of my friends was telling me about this topic a couple weeks ago, so I think I will e-mail them the url here and see what they say.

Alexis Mayone April 8, 2010 at 6:41 pm

great blog. I like the way you have it laid out. Which platform are you currently using? I’m thinking about setting up my blog this way.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: